Quakertown native Sabrina Carpenter celebrated her birthday in a yellow dress that ended up sparking a conversation on the ethics and prices of reselling, writes Emily Bloch for The Philadelphia Inquirer.

Carpenter’s stylist got the dress off Depop, a popular secondhand clothing app. The singer posted photos from her New York party over the weekend where she posed in a yellow satin slip.

The seller of the dress, Jules Berg, said the dress was a vintage piece from Caché.

Selling to a celebrity brought Berg popularity but also scrutiny and the ire of some users who found her pricing – and naming – unethical.

After going through her page, they found she listed 15-year-old shorts from Forever 21 and Abercrombie for hundreds of dollars.

But Berg said that is business as usual.

She thrifted the dress Carpenter wore for about $50 in New York, cropped it into a mini, and sold it to the singer’s team for $256. She describes the sale as a milestone.

“Never in my wildest dreams did I think that the dress I thrifted a few years ago would end up in Sabrina Carpenter’s closet,” she said.

Read more about Sabrina Carpenter and the controversial birthday dress in The Philadelphia Inquirer.

Barry Keoghan Celebrates Sabrina Carpenter’s Birthday with Surprise Party | TMZ